Society 12:38 19/01/2013

The Atlantic: Turkey's and Armenia's war over food

There is perhaps nothing more closely bound up with one's national identity than food. Specific local dishes are often seen as the embodiment of various cultures and many nations promote their food as a celebration of national identity. Sometimes, however, a country's cuisine can also be used to highlight national rivalries, says an article in The Atlantic. 

Czechs, for example, sometimes affectionately (some would say condescendingly) refer to their Slovak cousins as "Halusky" after the typical gnocchi dish that comprises part of their national cuisine. Similarly, the English often disparagingly call their French neighbors "Frogs" because of the Gallic penchant for eating the legs of said amphibians.

Culinary flashpoints can also arise when neighboring nations all lay claim to the same regional dish. For instance, the Scots, English, and the Irish often bicker about whose fried breakfast is the original and the best of the species.

In the volatile Caucasus region, though, it seems that such food fights have now been taken to a whole new level. As Eurasianet.org reports, many Armenians are up in arms about a recent UNESCO decision to add the Anatolian stew "Keshkek" to its Intangible Cultural Heritage List on behalf of Turkey. They claim that "Keshkek" is actually an Armenian meal, which they call "Harissa."

Now a group of ethnographers from Turkey's eastern neighbor are actually compiling information on the dish to appeal the ruling by the UN's cultural agency.

According to the News.am website, Sedrak Mamulyan, the chairman of the "Development and Preservation of Armenian Culinary Traditions" organization, is intent on demonstrating that "the utensils, methods, and ingredients used for making...Harissa have a pure Armenian origin and it is a purely Armenian dish." The same organization has also attacked Georgia for commandeering "Khash." It insists that this tasty beef soup is in fact an Armenian national dish.

Armenia, meanwhile, has itself come under fire from Azerbaijan, which has accused its neighbor and regional nemesis of "cuisine plagiarism." Baku's National Security Ministry has even set up a National Cuisine Center to reinforce its claim to the nation's cuisine and, in particular, to help counter any Armenian efforts to appropriate what it feels are Azerbaijani dishes.

The "Tolma" dish, which consists of meatballs wrapped in grape leaves, seems to be a particular bone of contention between the two countries, especially since Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev publicly announced last year that it was an Azeri national dish.

This provoked a furious response in Armenia and various initiatives have been launched to help save the country's national dishes from "occupants." This even includes holding an annual Tolma Festival to reinforce the idea that it is a typically Armenian food.

Whatever the upshot of these culinary claims and counterclaims, it sadly doesn't seem like these regional rivals will be sitting down to break bread with each other anytime soon.



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

17:00
Robert Kocharyan to skip re-consecration of Etchmiadzin cathedral
Second Armenian President Robert Kocharyan will not attend the blessing of the Holy Chrism (Muron) on Saturday and the re-consecration of the...
16:30
Analyst: Armenian authorities ready to make any concession to Azerbaijan and Turkey
The South Caucasus has never been a region of strategic importance for the United States, political analyst Suren Sargsyan claims. “No...
15:36
Temperatures to drop across Armenia
Rain is expected in Armenia’s regions on Saturday and next week. Foggy conditions are possible in some parts of the country, the...
14:58
Armenian, Latvian FMs meet in New York
On the sidelines of the 79th session of the UN General Assembly in New York, Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan on Saturday met...
14:35
MEP urges Azerbaijan to release Armenian prisoners
Member of the European Parliament (MEP) Fernand Kartheiser calls on Azerbaijan to guarantee Armenia’s territorial integrity, preserve...
14:05
Opposition MP: Azerbaijan put forward another precondition to Armenia
Azerbaijan has put forward another precondition for a peace deal with Armenia, opposition deputy Tigran Abrahamyan says. “Against the...
13:34
Armenia reports no new West Nile virus cases in one week
No new cases of West Nile fever were confirmed in Armenia in the past week, the National Center for Disease Control and Prevention reported on...
13:20
Israeli military says Hezbollah leader killed in Beirut strike
The Israeli military has said it has killed Hezbollah’s leader, Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah, in a series of strikes on a southern suburb of...
13:00
Armenian weightlifter Ashot Movsisyan wins bronze at Junior World Championships
Armenia's Ashot Movsisyan clinched a bronze medal at the IWF Junior World Weightlifting Championships in Leon, Spain on Friday. He...
12:30
Middle East on the brink of major war, Russia's Lavrov says
The Middle East is on the cusp of a major war, which "some people want very much," Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov said....
12:14
Serzh Sargsyan won't attend re-consecration of Etchmiadzin cathedral
Third Armenian President Serzh Sargsyan has refused to attend the blessing of the Holy Chrism (Muron) on Saturday and the re-consecration of the...
11:35
Armenia, Palestine establish diplomatic ties
Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan and Palestinian Prime Minister Mohammad Mustafa signed a joint declaration on establishing...
11:25
Armenian church commemorates St. George the Captain
The Armenian Apostolic Church on Saturday commemorates Sts George the Captain (George the Warrior), Adoktos and Romanos the Singer. St...
11:00
Noubar Afeyan calls for immediate release of Ruben Vardanyan, other Armenian prisoners
Entrepreneur and philanthropist Noubar Afeyan urges the Azerbaijani authorities to immediately release Ruben Vardanyan and all other...
17:03
Temperatures to drop further across Armenia
Scattered rain is expected in Armenia’s regions on Friday, Saturday and next week. Foggy conditions are possible in some parts of the...
16:30
Khachanov makes it to second round of China Open
Russian-Armenian Karen Khachanov, the No 7 seed, won against Spanish lucky loser Roberto Carballes Baena 6-4, 6-4 to move into the second round...
16:06
Opposition MP blames Pashinyan's government for 2020 war defeat
Opposition deputy Tigran Abrahamyan accused Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan's government of deliberately leading the country to defeat in the...
15:36
‘National disgrace': Opposition leader slams Pashinyan's meeting with Erdogan in New York
Seyran Ohanyan, the leader of the opposition Hayastan faction in the Armenian parliament, said opposition forces were striving to prevent the...
15:05
NSW MPs call on Australians to boycott COP29
Three members of the New South Wales Parliament have delivered powerful addresses on the floor of the Legislative Assembly to mark the first...
14:32
Archbishop Sahak Mashalyan arrives at Mother See
Archbishop Sahak Mashalyan, Armenian Patriarch of Constantinople, on Friday arrived at the Mother See of Holy Echmiadzin, the Armenian church...
14:04
Artsakh president commemorates 2020 war anniversary
Artsakh President Samvel Shahramanyan on Friday visited the Yerablur Military Pantheon in Yerevan to pay tribute to fallen soldiers on the...
13:30
Alen Simonyan to reportedly attend re-consecration of Etchmiadzin cathedral
Armenian National Assembly Speaker Alen Simonyan will attend the re-consecration ceremony of the Mother Cathedral in Etchmiadzin on Sunday,...
13:03
No decision yet on next stage of Armenian-Azeri border delimitation, official says
No decision has yet been made on the next stage of the Armenian-Azerbaijani border delimitation process, Armenian Deputy Prime Minister Mher...
12:34
Ruben Vardanyan, other Armenian leaders mark one year as political prisoners in Azerbaijan
Today marks the first anniversary of the arbitrary arrest by Azerbaijani authorities of eight Armenian leaders, commencing with the arrest of...
12:15
Ex-defense minister set to become Japan's next PM
After five tries, former Defense Minister Shigeru Ishiba will finally lead the Liberal Democratic Party — and Japan, The Japan Times...
12:03
Pashinyan at UN: Armenian proverb says, 'Let us speak the positive in order to be well'
As part of his working visit to New York, Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan on Thursday delivered a speech at the 79th session...
11:36
Armenian deputy PM acknowledges problems in relations with Russia
Armenian Deputy Prime Minister Mher Grigoryan acknowledged problems in relations with Russia and other countries. "We need to make...
11:15
Artsakh president pays tribute to fallen soldiers on war anniversary
Artsakh President Samvel Shahramyan on Friday visited the Yrablur Military Pantheon in Yerevan to pay homage to fallen soldiers on the...
11:00
Armenia, Azerbaijan agree to put additional efforts towards signing of peace deal
On September 26, under the initiative and with participation of U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken, Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat...
17:15
Wheat production in Armenia unprofitable, economy minister says
Wheat production in Armenia is economically unprofitable, Minister of Economy Gevorg Papoyan told reporters outside the Armenian government...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}