Interviews 10:39 01/05/2014

Elites use World Cup to solidify power – analyst

Press TV has conducted an interview with Harry Brown, an author and lecturer, in Dublin, about mass demonstrations in Brazil.

Press TV: The game of soccer, or football depending on where you live, has turned into this multi-billion dollar business, from the millions and more recently the tens of millions that are being paid to their players in terms of their salaries. Has money affected this sport?

Brown: Yes, of course. It affects it on the pitch and it affects it off the pitch. The expense of going to games in most of the European leagues has come beyond the capacity of most of the ordinary people who used to attend those matches.

The players themselves have entered into kind of a world of the super-rich - at least a small number of them have - that makes them quite remote from their origins.

And of course with projects like the World Cup, you have this massive infrastructure spending that is ultimately very profitable for the kind of cronies of the governments that host them so that for building contractors, infrastructure people there is enormous opportunity in the games.

Not only on the World Cup level, but something like the English Premier league, there is an enormous amount of money floating around – most of it of course coming from television; most of it ultimately paid for by ordinary people who buy tickets or buy subscriptions to satellite dishes or who pay by watching advertisements on a soccer game on television.

But it all comes from the enormous appetite for the game and incredibly there doesn’t seem to be any sign of this bubble bursting. It just keeps growing and growing.

Press TV: We could throw some figures in terms of what the players get paid in salary – I’m looking at the team Real Madrid, which has topped the list of teams making the most money - 3.3 billion dollars; Manchester United now worth 3.1 billion. These are astronomical figures.

Brown: Yes. Ten or 15 years ago, even American sports dwarfed football in terms of their salaries of players. Now, major soccer teams and great players are being paid as much or more than baseball players of American football players or basketball players.

Press TV: It is quite amazing when we take a look at these viewer comments... First, it shows how the politics of football has actually affected the viewers and how they view the game – and some of these comments are a testament to that.

Let’s look at Brazil, on which we focused in our report prior to talking to you... In Brazil, what is the government doing? It’s said that they are dealing with problems that has existed there, such as in the slums, regarding the peoples’ infrastructure, their lives being under such bad living standards that they’re experiencing there; and at the same time the government is spending all this money to try to clean up the slums.

So, that’s one of the controversies regarding the government spending on the World Cup versus how they are dealing with the ordinary people especially in the slums. Why is it that the government did not deal with this problem prior to the World Cup do you think?

Brown: Well, I think it comes back to the built-in corruption that’s part of the system and so you end up with the situation where the government, as part of its efforts to win the World Cup, persuades people that it’s going to improve infrastructure, improve education and it is ends up... that at the last minute it is actually driving poor people out of their homes in order to create this space.

But I think it’s important to say and a number of your commentators are sort of alienated from football for very good reasons: because of the money and because of this kind of sense that it’s this ‘weapon of distraction.’

But let’s look at Brazil and see that football, which is loved by so many millions, tens of millions of Brazilian people, has become a focus. For the very reason that football is so important to Brazilians - it’s become a focus for this protest. We’ve seen this in other countries before, indeed we’ve seen it in Iran in times when Iran is qualified for the World Cup and there have been protests around that. So, we know that the passion that people feel about football is not disconnected from the capacity to protest around it.

So I think we can view football and we can view this World Cup in a more positive light that this is an opportunity for Brazilians to bring their grievances onto the street, to have those grievances viewed and talked about by the whole world, I mean we’re talking about it on this program – we probably wouldn’t be talking about it if Brazil weren’t hosting the World Cup and if there wasn’t this football dimension to it.

So I think actually... Football is not really very important of course in reality, but it also is very important. And the fact that it arouses people’s passions means that it has political capacities that are uncontrollable.

We know that the Brazilian generals and the Argentine generals back in the1960s and 1970s thought that they could use the World Cup, thought that they could use football success to pacify the people, but it didn’t work.

I think that’s the important thing; there are politics of resistance in football as well as politics of repression.

Press TV: Our other guest (Isaac Bigio) talks about how the elite class is going to benefit. Based on the research done for this in terms of the economic factors and finances, it doesn’t appear that the nations that host the World Cup actually make money. They don’t even break even were they to make money – and we could refer to some of the previous World Cups.

Is it just a particular elite class making money off this or is it the fame that it brings for the host nation. Maybe you can clarify and explain that for us.

Brown: I think it is absolutely the question of elites benefitting, but in that sense football is like other realms of the economy and like other realms of society that the benefits are overwhelmingly channeled to the elite.

And an event like the World Cup is used as an opportunity by those elites to consolidate their power. They often, as we discussed earlier, they often get emergency powers to clear slum areas in order to build infrastructure in order to have quick profitable contracts for their friends. So it is part of the structure of society that football replicates.

And I guess what I’m saying is that it is also possible for people to take the game back and for the energies of football supporters to be used in a positive sense.

I was in Cairo last year for example and I know that a great deal of the kind of the revolutionary impetus on the streets around Tahrir Square were coming from supporters of the football club.

On the one hand, we have the horrors of some place like Qatar where we can see that the government there is indifferent not only to the concerns of ordinary people, but even to the workers on the stadiums themselves.

So we have football reflecting the divisions in everyday life in other realms as well.

I guess what I’m saying about football is that it is so important to people that football can also be a weapon by which we try to reclaim those spaces, to reclaim those streets where the real football is played and to say that these circuses like the World Cup are not going to distract us from the kind of solidarity and the kind of passion and the kind of joy that the game can still bring.

Press TV: Do you think that the spirit of the World Cup can be brought back into making it a sport that is being watched with passion minus the politics – As the adage goes, politics and sports should not mix?

Brown: I think it’s inevitable that politics and sports will mix and I think that as long as we have societies that are unequal, societies that are run by elites who use all aspects of that society to benefit themselves - It’s part of the structure of capitalism and of corporations that they must do these things - I think it’s inevitable that football will be tainted by it.

I think it’s impossible to pull sports and politics apart because sports are so important to people in societies that are political creatures and of course sporting clubs themselves have their own politics, their own debates, their own struggles within them.

So, God forbid sport and politics should be separated but I’m excited about Brazil in the World Cup in the football...



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

17:00
No Putin-Pashinyan meeting planned in St. Petersburg – Kremlin
A separate meeting between Russian President Vladimir Putin and Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan is not planned on the sidelines of the...
16:45
Blast at Turkey ammunition factory kills at least 12 people
An explosion at an ammunition and explosives factory in north-west Turkey has killed at least 12 people and injured four others, BBC News...
16:35
Best Armenian athletes of the year revealed
Armenia’s Ministry of Education, Science, Culture and Sports has named the best athletes of the year. The winners have been selected...
15:54
'We only need a competent leader': Armenians deplore plans to reduce working hours
Armenia’s Ministry of Labor and Social Affairs has proposed reducing working hours from eight to seven hours per day, which would not...
15:06
Putin to attend EAEU meeting chaired by Pashinyan
Russian President Vladimir Putin has left for St. Petersburg, where he will hold meetings with CIS heads of state and government in the coming...
14:23
Ex-ombudsman: Pashinyan's team using 'peace' propaganda to stay in power
The leaders of Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s Civil Contract party has transformed the “peace” propaganda into...
13:30
Russian cargo ship sinks in Mediterranean after explosion
A Russian cargo ship has sunk in the Mediterranean Sea between Spain and Algeria after an explosion in its engine room, the Guardian reported on...
13:19
Yerevan City Council member resigns
Areg Gevorgyan has stepped down as a member of the Yerevan City Council representing the ruling Civil Contract faction. At a meeting of the...
12:42
Income-earning jobs amounted to 782,832 in Armenia in November
According to the income tax and social payment declarations submitted by taxpayers for November 2024, the number of income-generating jobs...
12:16
Opposition MP: Pashinyan's comments confirm Artsakh issue remains unresolved
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s latest comments on Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) confirm that the Artsakh issue remains unresolved,...
11:35
Kremlin denies reports Bashar al-Assad's wife is seeking divorce
The British-born wife of deposed Syrian president Bashar al-Assad is not seeking a divorce, a Kremlin spokesman has said. Reports in Turkish...
11:15
Authorities warn of black ice on Syunik roads
The Rescue Service has warned drivers about a road closure in Armenia on Tuesday morning. In particular, the road linking the Amberd...
11:03
Armenian church commemorates St. Stephen the Protomartyr
The Armenian Apostolic Church on Tuesday commemorates St. Stephen, the first deacon and proto martyr. After Christ’s ascension,...
17:00
Artur Vanetsyan to be a guest on Imnemnimi podcast on December 25
Artur Vanetsyan, the leader of the Homeland Party and the former director of Armenia’s National Security Service (NSS), will be a guest on...
16:46
Dry weather expected on Monday
Dry weather is expected in Armenia's regions on Monday and later this week. Light snow is forecast for some parts of the country...
16:24
Hayakve condemns government's indifference towards Syrian Armenians
The Hayakve initiative has expressed concern about the fate of Syrian Armenians following the change of government in Syria. “We...
15:34
Politician slams Pashinyan's Artsakh claims as 'a blatant lie'
Opposition politician Eduard Sharmazanov, a senior member of the former ruling Republican Party of Armenia (RPA), has lambasted Armenian Prime...
14:33
Bashar al-Assad's wife reportedly files for divorce
The British wife of Syria’s deposed president Bashar al-Assad, Asma al-Assad, has filed for divorce after expressing dissatisfaction with...
14:07
Opposition MP: Armenian leaders focused on justifying themselves amid Azerbaijan's military buildup
The intensive mutual visits of Azerbaijani and Turkish military officials are largely part of a plan to reform Azerbaijan’s armed forces,...
13:30
Trump pledges to stop 'transgender lunacy'
President-elect Donald Trump on Sunday pledged to "stop the transgender lunacy" on day one of his presidency, AFP reported....
13:08
Yerevan mayor addresses criticism over expensive US trip
Yerevan Mayor Tigran Avinyan has addressed criticism over his expensive flight tickets for a trip to the U.S. in November. The...
12:34
Famous ophthalmologist Alexander Malayan dies at 76
Renowned ophthalmologist Alexander Malayan has passed away at the age of 76, YSMU Rector Armen Muradyan broke the news on Facebook on...
12:15
Boy injured as drones fall from sky at Florida holiday show
A holiday drone show in Florida was forced to cancel its second performance due to an injury this weekend. Andrea Otero, the City of Orlando...
12:06
Armenia ballet artists perform 'The Nutcracker' in Italy
Ballet artists from the Yerevan Opera Theater have started a concert tour to Italy to perform their adaptation of Pyotr Tchaikovsky's...
11:35
Pashinyan admits 'a big mistake' over Karabakh negotiation process
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan claims the Nagorno-Karabakh negotiation process completely focused on its return to Azerbaijan since the...
11:15
Drivers warned about icy roads in Armenia's Syunik
The Rescue Service has warned drivers about road closure in Armenia on Monday morning. In particular, the road linking the Amberd high...
11:00
Putin meets Slovak PM in Moscow
Russian President Vladimir Putin held surprise talks with Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico at the Kremlin on Sunday to discuss the future of...
17:30
Expert blasts My Step Foundation's 'unacceptable' response to Panorama.am
Shushan Doydoyan, President of the Freedom of Information Center of Armenia (FOICA), has denounced the My Step Charitable Foundation’s...
16:30
US avoids government shutdown with last-minute funding bill
The US Senate has voted to pass a budget deal to avert what would be the first federal government shutdown since 2019, only hours after the...
16:01
Barack Obama's top 10 movies of 2024 includes ‘Anora' starring Armenian actors
Barack Obama has shared his favorite movies of the year, continuing what has become an annual list-making tradition from the former...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}