Interviews 09:55 12/03/2015

‘Double standards – name of the international human rights game’

On the one hand, Australia has a certain pride in its human rights record, on the other - it allows the indefinite detention of asylum seekers and refugees who are considered security threats, Binoy Kampmark, lecturer at RMIT University, told RT.

UN Special Rapporteur on Torture, Juan Mendez, presented a report on Monday that revealed the Australian government’s mistreatment of asylum-seekers. The investigation found cases where children were being detained in offshore processing centers. The report also showed that authorities have been breaching global anti-torture conventions. In response Australian Prime Minister Tony Abbott said that the country was "sick of being lectured to by the United Nations.”

RT: Since 2013, the Australian government has applied a hard-line immigration policy and sent asylum seekers arriving on boats to Papua New Guinea's Manus Island and Nauru. Tony Abbott claimed that Australia has stopped the boats and ended the deaths at sea. Is the statement made by Mr. Abbott appropriate?

Binoy Kampmark: What Mr. Abbott has decided to do on this is to state that the number of boat arrivals has fallen - which is true. But what he doesn’t say is that the boat arrivals simply go elsewhere. So rather than stopping deaths at sea it is simply placing deaths elsewhere. I think it is a very important distinction to draw, because Mr. Abbott doesn’t say for example where the boats have gone, he simply says that they’ve stopped coming to Australia and that is a very significant difference. It’s not that deaths have lessened, it’s just deaths are taking place elsewhere.

The so-called operation “Sovereign Borders” …is the term the Australian government has used for dealing with these situations entirely secretly because there is no accountability in terms of what happens there, in terms of sea matters. We don’t actually know where some of these things go. Of course when it comes to individual boats, and so forth, the reporting is sketchy and poor. And then there is a broader issue, that if you stop refugees coming by one channel, they will always go through another channel and that is just a reality of the global refugee problem.

RT: Mr. Mendez replied by: "keeping people in prolonged arbitrary detention on the basis only of the fact that they attempted an irregular entry is a good course of action.” What is your take on that?

BK: What the Rapporteur on Torture, Mr. Mendez, has made clear is that the Refugee Convention entitles individuals to seek asylum in a country and not to be discriminated against in the basis of that right. The problem is that the Australian government obviously has demonstrated a lack of interest in what the refugee convention is obligating them to do. Australia as being a signatory must comply with that. That is obvious that it is not perceived to be a good vote-getter. It has sadly become a very bipartisan issue in Australia, in the sense that also the opposition believe in the main that foreign policy regarding asylum seekers is required. And that is what we tend to see constantly at the moment.

RT: Do you think that this statement by the Australian PM undermines the credibility of Abbott's government in the eyes of the international community?

BK: It’s very hard to undermine the credibility than it already is. The Abbott government is regarded as a sort of international joke in many ways. Let’s not forget that the same government with a Prime Minister who used this rather curious Australian expression called “shirtfronting”Russian President Vladimir Putin, and that was of course regarded as hilariously bizarre. His behavior, for example, at the G20 summit in Brisbane was considered rather peculiar and very parochial. So it’s not as if this behavior is considered surprising by his international counterparts. I don’t see another statement in terms of attacking a UN official is being that significantly more remarkable than what he has already done.

RT: Isn't this an example of double standards? The international community is free to criticize such countries as North Korea or Iran, for example, but it faces fierce backlash when deals with the human rights violations in the West.

BK: Yes, I’m afraid it is very true, the nature of human rights violations and the commentary on human rights violation is always tinged with that degree of double standards as you say. The reality of it is that a country, for example, like Australia will be able to or does have a certain pride, on the one hand, with its human rights record; and yet, it’s also a country that allows children to be detained and essentially allows in some cases indefinite detention of asylum seekers, and in some cases even refugees – those who have been found to be refugees - because they are considered security threats and because the domestic intelligence agency considers them a threat. So ‘double standards’ is very much the name of the international human rights game, I’m afraid. 



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

17:15
Adele bursts into tears as she embraces Céline Dion in Las Vegas
Adele is feeling the love from a fellow musical icon at her latest concert! The “Easy on Me” singer, 36, got emotional after...
16:59
Mass repatriation of Artsakh Armenians impossible without political processes, lawyer says
Human rights lawyer Siranush Sahakyan, who represents Armenian prisoners of war and their families at the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR),...
16:05
Lawyer insists on Armenia’s participation in COP29
Human rights lawyer Siranush Sahakyan, who represents Armenian prisoners of war and their families at the ECHR, insists on Armenia’s...
15:30
Armenia names new delegate to Miss Universe pageant
Armenia has named Emma Avanesyan as its delegate to the Miss Universe pageant to be held in Mexico on 16 November, Miss Universe...
15:06
Armenia's CEC sets dates for local elections in 2025
Armenia's Central Electoral Commission (CEC) has set March 30, June 8 and October 5 as dates for the local self-government elections in the...
14:35
Armenian Yerkrapah Union head under fire over latest remarks
Sasun Mikayelyan, the chairman of Armenia’s Yerkrapah Volunteer Union (Homeland Defenders Union), has come under fire after his remarks...
14:14
Civil society groups call for release of Armenian prisoners before COP29 in Baku
Dozens of Armenian civil society organizations have urged the parties to the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change and...
13:52
Armenia's defense spending set for rise in 2025, minister says
Armenia’s public expenditures are projected to rise by 5.4 percent to around 733 billion drams in 2025, Minister of Economy Vahe...
13:11
US, France and Armenia named top three buyers of Indian defence exports
With India shedding its hesitations in exporting lethal arms to other countries, Armenia has emerged as its biggest client of...
12:45
EU's Michel urges probe into Georgia election 'irregularities'
European Council President Charles Michel on Sunday pushed for a swift and transparent investigation of alleged irregularities during the...
12:30
Opposition MP slams Yerkrapah Union chief's remarks
Opposition lawmaker Tigran Abrahamyan has denounced the latest statement of Sasun Mikayelyan, the chair of Armenia’s Yerkrapah Volunteer...
12:04
Francesco Totti hints at return to football
Roma and Italy icon Francesco Totti has hinted that he could come out of retirement at 48 amid interest from some Serie A clubs, GOAL...
11:33
Temperatures to drop in Armenia tonight
Clear weather is expected in Armenia this week. Temperatures are set to further fall by 2-3C on Monday night. Freezing temperatures are...
11:15
Georgian president won't recognize election results, calls for protests
Pro-Western Georgian President Salome Zurabishvili, who has broken with the ruling Georgian Dream party, said she will not recognize the results...
11:00
Armenia's Alexandra Grigoryan wins gold at European Junior & U23 Championships
Armenia's Alexandra Grigoryan has clinched a gold medal at the European Junior and U23 Championships being held in Raszyn, Poland, from...
17:03
Death toll from tropical storm in Philippines climbs to 81
The death toll from tropical storm Trami that slammed into the Philippines this week has risen to 81, with around 20 other people still missing,...
16:51
Armenian wrestler beats Azeri, Turkish rivals at U23 World Championships
Armenian freestyle wrestler Manvel Khndzrtsyan (57 kg) on Saturday outcompeted his Azerbaijani and Turkish opponents to advance to the...
16:12
Comedian Mikhail Galustyan celebrates 45th birthday
Russian-Armenian actor, comedian and showman Mikhail Galustyan celebrated his 45th birthday on October 25. Galustyan was born in...
15:31
Greta Thunberg visits Turkish radio station closed over Armenian genocide row
Swedish climate activist Greta Thunberg on Friday visited Istanbul's Acik Radyo, whose broadcasts were silenced earlier this month by...
15:00
Temperatures dropping in Armenia
Rain is expected in some parts of Armenia on Saturday and overnight Sunday with snow set to hit the country’s mountainous regions....
14:36
Iran says has inherent right to self-defense after Israeli attack
The Iranian Foreign Ministry denounces Israel's aggressive actions against certain military installations in Iran, characterizing them as a...
14:06
Expert: Outcome of Georgian elections decisive for Armenia
The ongoing elections in Georgia promise to be decisive for Armenia’s further engagement with the European Union, US foreign policy expert...
13:30
Netherlands to host benefit concert honoring Artsakh war hero
On November 2, at 3 p.m., a benefit concert dedicated to the indelible memory of Artsakh war hero Aren Mehrabyan will be held in the church of...
13:02
PSG still refuse to pay €55m to Kylian Mbappe
Paris Saint-Germain have again refused to pay Kylian Mbappe €55 million (£46m/$59m) in unpaid wages and will take the matter to...
12:45
Armenian expert: Israeli strikes on Iran ‘went unnoticed’ by many Iranians
Iran specialist Vardan Voskanyan has weighed in on Israel’s overnight attacks on Iran. In a social media post on Saturday, he cited...
12:14
Israel launches strikes on Iran
Israel launched its long-awaited retaliatory strikes on Iran early Saturday local time, CBS News reported, citing the Israeli military....
12:03
Armenian church commemorates Twelve Holy Teachers
The Armenian Apostolic Church on Saturday commemorates the Twelve Holy Teachers (Doctors) of the Church, namely Hierotheus of Athens, Dionysius...
11:45
EU must stop 'lecturing' world, Michel says
The participation of EU partner nations in a summit in Russia hosted by Vladimir Putin is a message for Brussels to stop “lecturing”...
11:35
Armenia sets up working group on visa liberalization with EU
Armenia has established a working group to coordinate visa liberalization talks with the EU. The group led by Deputy Prime Minister Mher...
11:21
Vienna Open: Khachanov through to semi-finals
Russian-Armenian Karen Khachanov moved into the semi-finals of the Vienna Open by winning against Italian Matteo Berrettini 6-1, 6-4 at the...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}