Interviews 18:25 08/05/2015

Patrick Dumberry: Turkey is exact same state as Ottoman Empire under international law

In the framework of the Armenian Genocide Centennial a Global Forum Against the Crime of Genocide  was held in Yerevan on 22 – 23 April. The forum featured over 600 participants from more than 50 countries, among them scholars, experts, high-ranking officials, parliamentarians, clerics and others who discussed various aspects of genocide. 

Nvard Chalikyan from Panorama.am has conducted a series of interviews with the international guests.

Below we present to your attention interview with Dr. Patrick Dumberry, Professor of law at the University of Ottawa (Canada), on the issue of sate succession in the case of Turkey and other legal aspects concerning Armenian Genocide reparations.


 

Professor Dumberry, who has examined this issue in detail, says that “Turkey is the exact same state as the Ottoman Empire”. This link is important when the question of paying reparations for the Armenian Genocide is raised. 

“Under the international law there is that link and they cannot deny [it]. Potentially there is also the issue of compensation that would arise from this crime, even if it were committed a hundred years ago, that doesn’t matter”, - he says, noting that some Turkish scholars have recently also admitted that this link between Ottoman Empire and Turkey does exist. 

Dr. Bumberry addresses the arguments advanced by Turkey aimed at denying Turkey’s responsibility for the criminal acts of the Ottoman Empire, and presents counter-arguments to these claims.

Contrary to the argument that Turkey has changed so much as a state and as a society that it does not bear any responsibility for the acts of the Ottomans, Dr. Dumberry says that in legal terms that is irrelevant.

“What is relevant is whether or not the core of the Turkish state and nation still existed after 1923, which is the casem” he says.

He also highlights the fact that “all the states have refused to recognize Turkey as a new state” and “they have wanted Turkey to be responsible for the wrong and also for the debt of the Ottoman Empire”, with the Lausanne treaty indicating this clearly.

Addressing the question of Sevres Treaty and the Woodrow Wilson Award as possible grounds for territorial reparations from Turkey at some point, Dr. Dumberry notes that the Award (which determined large territories for Armenia that are now Turkish territory) is valid under the international law, however he warns that the issue of borders is a very sensitive and explosive one. He therefore does not advise Armenia to pursue the path of changing borders as a means of reparations, as he believes this will not be feasible politically and will lead nowhere. Dr. Dumberry instead advises to seek reparation, restitution of Church property or restitution of lost houses as well as a global settlement of money to be given to the victims.

He also notes that the legal paths to address this issue are very limited. For instance in order to take the case to the International Court of Justice both parties must have consented to the jurisdiction of the court, while Turkey hasn’t done so – this means that Turkey cannot be brought to the tribunal; and there is no other tribunal or venue.

He thus believes that these issues ultimately find political rather than legal solution. So in political terms he advises to continue the path of the international recognition of the Armenian Genocide which may eventually compel Turkey to recognize it. 

To the question of whether or not it is necessary for Turkey to recognize the Genocide in order for it to pay reparations, Dr. Dumberry answers that Turkey can still pay reparations by refraining from formal recognition of the Genocide. He cites the example of Germany, which did not recognize its legal responsibility for the Holocaust but recognized its moral responsibility and paid millions of dollars as compensation. So even though recognition would be desirable, it is not a necessary condition for paying reparations. But for this too a political will, he says, will be needed.

Dr. Patrick Dumberry is the author of over 50 publications in the field of international law, among them 'State Succession to International Responsibility’ (2007). Among his articles on this subject are The Consequences of Turkey Being the ‘Continuing’ State of the Ottoman Empire in Terms of International Responsibility for Internationally Wrongful Acts and Is Turkey the ‘Continuing’ State of the Ottoman Empire Under International Law? 


Interview by Nvard Chalikyan


Related interviews:

William Schabas: Term Genocide may be applied to events of 1915, contrary to some governments’ claims against using it
 
EP Vice-President Ryszard Czarnecki on Genocide recognition: “Silence means support” 

MEP Massimo Castaldo on Armenian Genocide Resolution: We cannot sacrifice human rights to commercial interests  



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

17:16
Government refuses to disclose number of security officers accompanying Anna Hakobyan to Italy
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s wife, Anna Hakobyan, was accompanied by the State Protection Service and protocol officers...
16:35
Pashinyan reaffirms his government's commitment to peace agenda
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan on Monday held a phone conversation with António Costa, President of the European Council....
15:50
Opposition politician: Pashinyan leading Armenia to 'capitulation'
Opposition politician Eduard Sharmazanov has denounced Prime Minister Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s claims about “historical...
14:45
Gold market employees protest tax hike in Yerevan
Jewelers and traders from the gold market in Armenia on Monday gathered outside the government building in central Yerevan to protest...
14:27
Armenia has no plans to quit EAEU, minister says
Minister of Economy Gevorg Papoyan claims that Armenia has no intention to leave the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU). “We want to...
13:36
Human rights lawyer Arsen Babayan releases arrest footage
Human rights lawyer Arsen Babayan, a member of the opposition Homeland Party led by former NSS director Artur Vanetsyan, on Saturday released...
13:06
Elina Avanesyan improves position in WTA rankings
Armenia's Elina Avanesyan has improved her position in the WTA rankings. She moved up three sports to 41st in the updated...
12:36
Opposition MP criticizes Pashinyan's mutual arms control proposal to Azerbaijan
Opposition lawmaker Tigran Abrahamyan has criticized Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan's proposal to establish a mutual arms control mechanism...
11:45
Ancelotti slams Real Madrid after crushing defeat to Barcelona
Carlo Ancelotti said he was "sad and disappointed" after Real Madrid's 5-2 Supercopa final defeat to Barcelona in Jeddah, Saudi...
11:21
Drivers warned of foggy conditions in parts of Armenia
The Rescue Service has warned drivers of a road closure and foggy weather conditions in Armenia as of Monday morning. In...
11:05
Armenian church celebrates naming of Jesus
The Armenian Apostolic Church celebrates the Feast of the Holy Name of Our Lord Jesus Christ each year on January 13, Qahana.am reports. As...
17:24
Airborne dust in Yerevan exceeds hygiene standards, expert warns
The dust levels in Yerevan’s air exceed hygiene standards, according to Aram Gabrielyan, an expert at the Khazer NGO and a specialist in...
16:33
Armenian Assembly of America stands united with Armenian community amid Los Angeles fires
The Armenian Assembly of America issued the following statement in the wake of the devastating Los Angeles wildfires: The Armenian...
16:06
Tigran Mansurian's 'Requiem' to be performed at Prague festival
The 8th Eternal Hope Music Festival will be held in Prague, the Czech Republic, from February 2 to March 20. The final part of the...
15:30
Trump, Zuckerberg meet at Mar-a-Lago
Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg met with Donald Trump at Mar-a-Lago on Friday, a source familiar with their encounter confirmed to Semafor....
15:12
Snow, fog expected in Armenia
Dry weather is expected in Armenia's regions over the weekend and early next week. Yerevan will also remain free of precipitation during...
14:36
EU to analyze Armenia integration bill
The EU will analyze the bill on the process of Armenia’s EU integration and discuss it with Yerevan, the lead spokesperson of the EU for...
14:18
Archbishop addresses Azerbaijan's fresh threats against Armenia
Archbishop Bagrat Galstanyan, the leader of the Holy Struggle movement, has denounced the Armenian leadership’s failure to respond to...
13:45
No Armenian citizens among Los Angeles wildfire victims – Foreign Ministry
No Armenian citizens have been identified among the casualties of the devastating wildfires in Los Angeles, the Armenian Foreign...
13:15
Primary elections underway in Armenia's Parakar
Primary elections commenced in Armenia’s enlarged Parakar community on Saturday to run through Monday. The ruling Civil...
12:36
At least 11 dead in Los Angeles wildfires
California Governor Gavin Newsom called for an investigation Friday into Los Angeles County’s fire hydrant and other water failures as...
12:19
Pashinyan considers appealing to OSCE over Minsk Group dissolution
Armenia is mulling an appeal to the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) to dissolve its Minsk Group on...
11:55
Henrikh Mkhitaryan could miss Inter's Serie A clash with Venezia
Inter Milan midfielder Henrikh Mkhitaryan is a doubt for the Nerazzurri’s Serie A clash with Venezia this weekend, SempreInter.com...
11:36
Armenia to host Iranian parliamentary delegation
A delegation of the Iran-Armenia Friendship Group from the Majlis of the Islamic Republic of Iran, led by its head Ara Shahverdyan, will travel...
11:15
Fog engulfs parts of Armenia
The Rescue Service has warned drivers of a road closure in Armenia. In particular, the road connecting the Amberd high mountain...
17:13
EU could extend monitoring mission in Armenia through 2027
The High Representative of the European Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy, Kaja Kallas, has proposed a two-year extension of the...
16:45
Putin ready for talks with Trump, Kremlin says
The Kremlin said Friday that President Vladimir Putin was open to talks with Donald Trump, after the incoming US president said a meeting...
16:34
Armenian FM, EU envoy discuss security situation in South Caucasus
Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan on Friday had a meeting with the EU Special Representative for the South Caucasus and the crisis in...
16:05
Yeghishe Charents' book sent into space on museum anniversary
The 60th anniversary of the founding and the 50th anniversary of the opening of the Yeghishe Charents House-Museum in Yerevan have been...
15:36
Pashinyan 'unaware' of developments in Armenia, ex-advisor says
Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan on Thursday claimed that the number of air passengers arriving in Armenia increased by 20% between January 1...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}