Politics 15:57 07/06/2016 World

Tessa Hofmann: German Resolution Implies Impulses for Armenian Genocide Education and Research

Dr. Tessa Hofmann, prominent German scholar of Armenian studies and a strong advocate for the recognition and condemnation of the Armenian Genocide, said in an interview with Nvard Chalikyan that the German Bundestag resolution (02 June) was important as it stated that the ‘massacres’ and ‘expulsion’ of the Ottoman Armenians “constitute a crime of genocide” – with this act the German legislator became the 26th national legislator confirming the crimes of the Ottoman Turkey against the Armenian people of 1915-16 as Genocide. At the same time she expressed her disappointment with the fact that the German Chancellor and the foreign Minister didn’t take part in the voting; she also regretted that the resolution didn’t include an apology to the Armenians for the role the Imperial Germany played in the Armenian Genocide.

“For most Armenians the resolution was a very moving event that marked the formal recognition of the Ottoman state crimes by the German successor state which was once in alliance with the Young Turkish regime of genocidal perpetrators… Regrettably, the head of the government, her deputy and also the Foreign Minister were absent during the debate and voting”.

“Second, the German legislators missed their chance to apologize before the Armenian people for role that Imperial Germany played during WW1. At that time the German government remained indolent despite its precise information on the scope and details of the destruction of Ottoman Armenians”, – she said, reminding that Germany also benefitted from Armenian slave labor at the Baghdad railway construction.

“For me, it is not good enough to acknowledge legally and academically well explored facts 101 years post factum without making a convincing human gesture”, – she said.  

Speaking about the effect the resolution will have in Germany, Dr. Hofmann noted that it marks the official recognition of the commemoration of the descendants of those victims in Germany. “More positively, the text of the German resolution implies impulses for education and research, provided that future decision-makers were interested in this and do not give in to the threats of influential Turkish NGOs in Germany… [I]t remains to be seen how the implementation of the resolution’s impulses in genocide awareness education and research on the Ottoman genocide(s) will progress”, – she said.

As for the reaction of Turkey to the resolution (i.e. calling back its ambassador from Berlin and calling the German ambassador to Ankara to the Turkish FO for official protest), Dr. Hofmann called it “a blend of organized ‘anger of the people’ and official threats, thinly disguised as the ‘warnings’ of President Erdoğan”.

Turkey argues that parliaments are not entitled to play the role of courts or historiography and the German legislators have emphasized that this resolution is not a legal verdict; however, Dr. Hofmann recalled that a legal verdict had already been issued by Ottoman Court Martials during 1919 and 1920, but was subsequently cancelled by the Kemalist counter-government in Ankara.

The German historian is skeptical with regard to Erdoğan’s announcement on possible cancellation of the EU-Turkey agreement on refugees, and agrees with the experts that both Germany and Turkey will carefully separate the issue of refugee policies from the ‘Armenia resolution’ and that the Turkish ambassador will soon return to his office in Berlin, as it happened in all previous cases.

Speaking about the prehistory of this resolution, Dr. Hofmann noted that the German Bundestag had been confronted with the demand to recognize the Armenian genocide (together with the Ottoman genocides against Aramaic speaking and Greek Orthodox Christians) for 16 years, and that to a large extent it was Pope Francis’ recognition of the Armenian Genocide that made the necessary shift.

In 2005, the Bundestag issued a non-legislative resolution in which it commemorated the ‘massacres’ and ‘expulsion’ of the Ottoman Armenians, admitting German involvement into the Ottoman genocide. “Scholars of genocide, human rights NGOs and Armenian communities of Germany have rightly criticized the resolution of 2005 for its avoidance of the term ‘genocide’, or its German synonym ‘voelkermord’”, – she said.

As a result of this criticism, a new initiative started at the occasion of the centenary, when MP Dr. Christoph Bergner of the ruling conservative party introduced a new resolution draft which contained the term ‘voelkermord’, albeit hidden in a complicated sentence at the end of the third paragraph. The German executive (government) nevertheless stopped even this very soft version of recognition in order not to provoke Turkey, Tessa Hofmann noted.   

“Only after the address of Pope Francis on 12 April 2015 the German Bundestag reconsidered its position”, she highlighted, recalling that after the Pope’s message speakers of all fractions used the term ‘voelkermord’ during their speeches on 24 April 2015, but it was too late for any voting of the three pending resolution drafts. They were sent to the parliamentary Committee for Foreign Affairs. On 25 February 2016, the oppositional Green Fraction withdrew its draft resolution, after the chairman of the ruling party had agreed to an inter-fractional resolution, which was issued on 02 June.

Tessa Hofmann is a renowned German scholar of Armenian studies (author of over a dozen books on Armenian history, culture and the Armenian Genocide); she is also an outspoken human rights activist.

Interview by Nvard Chalikyan



Source Panorama.am
Share |
Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

17:00
Armenia’s top diplomat may visit Russia soon, Lavrov says
Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan may visit Russia before long, TASS quoted Russia's top diplomat Sergey Lavrov as saying on...
16:30
ANCA submits testimony in support of Marco Rubio's confirmation as US secretary of state
The Armenian National Committee of America (ANCA) has submitted testimony to the Senate Foreign Relations Committee supporting Senator Marco...
16:13
Narek Hakhnazaryan to offer master classes at Yerevan music schools
The Yerevan Municipality has announced the launch of the 2025 edition of the "Your Art at School" program. From February 1 to...
15:30
Light snow, fog expected in Armenia
Dry weather is expected in Armenia on Tuesday. Light snow is forecast for some regions over the coming days, with foggy conditions and...
15:00
Lavrov: Armenia's aspiration to join EU incompatible with EAEU membership
Armenia's membership in the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU) is incompatible with its desire to join the European Union (EU), as these...
14:47
Ameriabank raises $200 million from IFC, marking largest transaction by IFC ever with a financial institution in Armenia
Ameriabank has signed a $200 million long-term loan agreement with the International Finance Corporation (IFC) to support climate finance...
14:35
Protest for release of Armenian prisoners to be held outside UN office in Yerevan
A protest demanding the immediate release of Armenian prisoners held in Baku will take place outside the UN office in Yerevan on Friday, to...
14:00
Kremlin reacts to Armenia-US strategic partnership plans
The development of strategic partnership between Armenia and the United States is the sovereign right of Yerevan; Russia, for its part, intends...
13:35
Expert explains what US strategic partnership deal means for Armenia
Political analyst Suren Sargsyan has shared his insights on the strategic partnership agreement to be signed between Armenia and the...
13:01
Australian Open: Elina Avanesyan loses to Putintseva
Kazakh Yulia Putintseva, the No 24 seed, moved into the second round of the Australian Open by defeating Armenian Elina Avanesyan 4-6, 7-5, 6-2...
12:34
Minister reports moderate situation of acute respiratory infections in Armenia
The situation regarding acute respiratory infections, including COVID-19 and influenza, is currently stable in Armenia. At a press...
12:04
Former ruling party MP sees early elections in Armenia
Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan will call fresh parliamentary elections in the coming months, a lawmaker ousted from his Civil Contract party...
11:46
Armenia, US to sign strategic partnership document
Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan and U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken will sign a document on strategic partnership between the...
11:30
Australian Open: Khachanov through to second round
Russian-Armenian Karen Khachanov, the No 19 seed, advanced to the second round of the Australian Open by defeating Frenchman Adrian Mannarino...
11:15
Armenian church marks Nativity of St. John the Baptist
The Armenian Apostolic Church celebrates the Nativity of Saint John the Baptist (Forerunner) on Tuesday 14 January. The elderly couple...
17:16
Government refuses to disclose number of security officers accompanying Anna Hakobyan to Italy
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s wife, Anna Hakobyan, was accompanied by the State Protection Service and protocol officers...
16:35
Pashinyan reaffirms his government's commitment to peace agenda
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan on Monday held a phone conversation with António Costa, President of the European Council....
15:50
Opposition politician: Pashinyan leading Armenia to 'capitulation'
Opposition politician Eduard Sharmazanov has denounced Prime Minister Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s claims about “historical...
14:45
Gold market employees protest tax hike in Yerevan
Jewelers and traders from the gold market in Armenia on Monday gathered outside the government building in central Yerevan to protest...
14:27
Armenia has no plans to quit EAEU, minister says
Minister of Economy Gevorg Papoyan claims that Armenia has no intention to leave the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU). “We want to...
13:36
Human rights lawyer Arsen Babayan releases arrest footage
Human rights lawyer Arsen Babayan, a member of the opposition Homeland Party led by former NSS director Artur Vanetsyan, on Saturday released...
13:06
Elina Avanesyan improves position in WTA rankings
Armenia's Elina Avanesyan has improved her position in the WTA rankings. She moved up three sports to 41st in the updated...
12:36
Opposition MP criticizes Pashinyan's mutual arms control proposal to Azerbaijan
Opposition lawmaker Tigran Abrahamyan has criticized Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan's proposal to establish a mutual arms control mechanism...
11:45
Ancelotti slams Real Madrid after crushing defeat to Barcelona
Carlo Ancelotti said he was "sad and disappointed" after Real Madrid's 5-2 Supercopa final defeat to Barcelona in Jeddah, Saudi...
11:21
Drivers warned of foggy conditions in parts of Armenia
The Rescue Service has warned drivers of a road closure and foggy weather conditions in Armenia as of Monday morning. In...
11:05
Armenian church celebrates naming of Jesus
The Armenian Apostolic Church celebrates the Feast of the Holy Name of Our Lord Jesus Christ each year on January 13, Qahana.am reports. As...
17:24
Airborne dust in Yerevan exceeds hygiene standards, expert warns
The dust levels in Yerevan’s air exceed hygiene standards, according to Aram Gabrielyan, an expert at the Khazer NGO and a specialist in...
16:33
Armenian Assembly of America stands united with Armenian community amid Los Angeles fires
The Armenian Assembly of America issued the following statement in the wake of the devastating Los Angeles wildfires: The Armenian...
16:06
Tigran Mansurian's 'Requiem' to be performed at Prague festival
The 8th Eternal Hope Music Festival will be held in Prague, the Czech Republic, from February 2 to March 20. The final part of the...
15:30
Trump, Zuckerberg meet at Mar-a-Lago
Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg met with Donald Trump at Mar-a-Lago on Friday, a source familiar with their encounter confirmed to Semafor....

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}