Politics 16:43 04/10/2019 Armenia

The status of Artsakh and punctuation marks

Author Anna Mkrtchyan

When Russia announces that Crimea is Russia, what punctuation mark does it put in the end – a period, exclamation point or suspension point?

Naturally, the conflicts of Crimea and Nagorno-Karabakh have different origins, history and dynamics, but it’s not possible to avoid the temptation of drawing parallels between them when the Russian foreign minister compares Armenia and Albania in the context of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict.

Speaking at the Valdai Forum in Sochi on October 2, Lavrov touched upon the Karabakh conflict, noting that “the situation is much calmer now than a year ago, but the political process is stalled and attempts to advance it has been failing."

“The parties are making quite serious statements. In particular, there has been a statement that ‘Karabakh is Armenia’, just like Albanian prime minister announced from Tirana that ‘Kosovo is Albania’. Such statements certainly do not contribute to the formation of an atmosphere conducive to the resumption of the political process,” Lavrov said.

Yesterday, the Armenian Foreign Ministry responded to this statement, not in a tough but quite a persistent manner. Reaffirming Armenia’s position, the Foreign Ministry deemed it important for the mediators to avoid one-sided and selective assessments.

Around two months later, Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev also referred to the Armenian prime minister’s “Artsakh is Armenia; period” remark during the same Valdai Forum. First, he dismissed the statement as “a lie”, since “the whole world recognizes Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan” and “Karabakh is an indigenous territory of Azerbaijan”, adding: “Therefore, Karabagh is Azerbaijan and exclamation point.”

It turns out that Russian FM Lavrov provided a background for the Azerbaijani president, giving him the courage to be able to make the mentioned statement.

In Russian, an exclamation point is put at the end of sentences that express surprise, strong emotions, excitement, etc. It isn’t clear in what state President Ilham Aliyev was when making that statement, was he surprised or excited? But obviously he is able to surprise others with his ability to repeat the same fruitless view many times.

Speaking about the Armenian PM’s statement that the settlement of the conflict should be acceptable to the peoples of Armenia, Nagorno-Karabakh and Azerbaijan, he again voiced the provision of Azerbaijani propaganda that there is no such thing as people of Nagorno-Karabakh, there is only Karabakh population. And what kind of solution is acceptable to Aliyev? Of course, the restoration of Azerbaijan's territorial integrity.

The Azerbaijani leader has repeatedly presented the same theses from different floors and with different punctuation marks, in essence predetermining the outcomes of the negotiations. Whereas, Russia has never tried to compare Azerbaijan with Ukraine and accuse it of imposing a military solution to the conflict.

If the maximalist dreams of one side can be accepted and considered realistic, then similar positions of the other side must also be heard. 



Source Panorama.am
Share |

Related news

Տեքստում սխալ կամ վրիպակ նկատելու դեպքում, ուղարկեք խմբագրին հաղորդագրություն` նշելով տվյալ սխալը, այնուհետև սեղմելով Ctrl-Enter:

Newsfeed

17:04
Filmmaker: Turkish-Azerbaijani-Armenian trio putting democracy on trial
Filmmaker and publicist Hovhannes Ishkhanyan has condemned the prosecution of opposition figure Edgar Ghazaryan, accusing the Armenian...
16:35
Avetik Chalabyan condemns 'disgraceful' prosecution of opposition figure
Public and political figure Avetik Chalabyan, coordinator of the HayaKve initiative, has denounced the "disgraceful"...
16:13
Snow to persist in parts of Armenia
Snow will persist in some parts of Armenia over the weekend, with blizzards and low visibility expected in the country’s mountainous...
15:35
Archbishop condemns activist Edgar Ghazaryan’s prosecution
Archbishop Bagrat Galstanyan, the leader of the Holy Struggle movement, has expressed full support for opposition figure Edgar Ghazaryan,...
15:06
Around 700 Armenian trucks stuck at Russia-Georgia border
Approximately 700 Armenian trucks are stuck in a long que at the Upper Lars checkpoint on the Russia-Georgia border, the Traffic Management...
14:35
Five lawyers to take on activist Edgar Ghazaryan's defense
The Five Human Rights Defenders Initiative will provide legal defense for public and political activist Edgar Ghazaryan, who is facing charges...
14:01
California governor requests nearly $40 billion in wildfire recovery funding
California Gov. Gavin Newsom requested nearly $40 billion in wildfire recovery aid in a letter to members of Congress on Friday, CNN...
13:36
Yerevan residents have rare chance to breathe clean air after heavy snow
The recent abundant snowfall in Yerevan has brought about a positive outcome. After years of breathing polluted air, the residents of the...
13:15
Armenian activist denies charges, demands accountability for prosecutors
Public and political activist Edgar Ghazaryan, former Armenian ambassador to Poland, has rejected the charges against him, demanding...
12:36
Ex-ombudsman slams charges against activist Edgar Ghazaryan
Former Human Rights Defender Arman Tatoyan has lambasted the prosecution of public and political activist Edgar Ghazaryan, calling it an...
12:06
Mkhitaryan among most valuable players aged 34 and older
The football portal Transfermarkt has updated its market valuations for players aged 34 and older, with former Armenian team captain...
11:35
Lawyer: Political activist Edgar Ghazaryan charged for critical remarks
Public and political activist Edgar Ghazaryan has been charged over his critical comments about judges, his lawyer Ruben Melikyan...
11:04
Another Azerbaijani journalist arrested
Baku’s Khatai District Court has remanded journalist Nurlan (Libre) Gahramanli to one month and 15 days in pre-trial detention....
17:06
Expert: Government undermines reputation of Armenian language
Political analyst Menua Soghomonyan, co-founder of the HayaKve initiative, accused Armenia’s current government of failing to prioritize...
16:30
WCC expresses solidarity with Armenian Patriarchate of Jerusalem facing unjust foreclosure
The World Council of Churches (WCC) on Thursday issued a statement expressing solidarity with the Armenian Patriarchate in Jerusalem in the...
16:03
Armenia sees sharp decline in tourist arrivals
The number of tourists visiting Armenia sharply declined in January this year. It appears that the millions of drams spent on the city’s...
15:35
George Aghjayan to serve as ANCA’s national chairman
The Armenian National Committee of America (ANCA) has announced that longtime Armenian American activist and grassroots leader George Aghjayan...
15:00
Baku orders suspension of BBC News Azerbaijani
The Azerbaijani government has ordered the suspension of BBC News' Azerbaijani operation in the capital city, Baku. The BBC said in a...
14:36
Lawyer: Appellate court sends Avinyan's lawsuit against Pastinfo back for retrial
The Civil Court of Appeals on Friday upheld Pastinfo’s appeal in a case involving Yerevan Mayor Tigran Avinyan and the Armenian National...
13:46
Woman attacked with axe in her home in Jerusalem's Armenian Quarter
A woman in her 50s was attacked in her home in the Armenian Quarter of Jerusalem's Old City, Magen David Adom announced on Wednesday...
13:25
MP: Azerbaijan using sham trials of Armenian prisoners as 'a deadly weapon' against Armenia
Opposition Pativ Unem faction MP Tigran Abrahamyan has reacted to a recent message from Ruben Vardanyan, an Armenian businessman and...
12:45
Americans, Russians reportedly discussed Ukraine war through Swiss side channel
U.S. and Russian participants have quietly met in Switzerland for unofficial discussions about the Ukraine war in recent months, including as...
12:30
MP urges OSCE to send monitoring mission to Baku to observe sham trials of Armenian prisoners
Lilit Galstyan, a member of the Armenian National Assembly who is part of the OSCE Parliamentary Assembly (PA) delegation, delivered a speech at...
12:06
Number of political prisoners growing in Azerbaijan
According to a report by one of Azerbaijan’s human rights organizations dated December 12, 2024, there were 331 political prisoners in the...
11:45
Chinese team finds new bat coronavirus
A Chinese team has found a new bat coronavirus that carries the risk of animal-to-human transmission because it uses the same human receptor as...
11:32
YSU shifts to online classes amid bad weather
Yerevan State University (YSU) today announced a shift to remote classes due to adverse weather conditions. The university classes typically...
11:10
Russian envoy slightly injured in traffic accident in Yerevan
Russian Ambassador to Armenia Sergey Kopyrkin’s motor vehicle on Thursday had a traffic accident due to heavy snowfall in Yerevan with the...
17:06
Gyumri to hold municipal elections on March 30
At a meeting on Thursday, the Central Electoral Commission (CEC) set March 30 as the date for early municipal elections in Gyumri,...
16:35
Analyst: US, Russia need to rebuild trust to resolve global issues
Panorama.am interviewed Sergei Melkonian, a historian, political analyst and research fellow at APRI Armenia, about the statements...
15:35
Hamas returns bodies of 4 Israeli hostages
Hamas on Thursday handed over the bodies of four Israeli hostages held in Gaza — the first time the group has released deceased captives...

Follow us and get updates!

Most popular articles

{"core.blocks.header.spell_message1":"Selected mistake: ","core.blocks.header.spell_message2":"Send a message about the mistake?"}